Debunking The Show-Cause Myth


I recently read an article detailing the 10 most misunderstood words in the English language.  The list contained words like infamous, historical, systematic, & alternate.  There were also some words I'm guilty of using incorrectly such as nauseous, precocious, & moot. Since the Bruce Pearl debate has really heated up lately, that article inspired me to write one of my own because never has a sports term been more misunderstood than the NCAA show-cause penalty.  After educating myself on what it actually means, I decided to debunk the myths surrounding this dreaded word.

            _______________________________________________________

MYTH
The show-cause penalty is intended to destroy a coach's career & schools who hire a coach with one on his resume' will be highly scrutinized by the NCAA.  In other words, a show-cause is shorthand for a coach becoming unhireable in collegiate athletics.

REALITY
The intent of a show-cause is to keep a coach from fleeing the school receiving the sanctions to coach another program unscathed.  Without it, there is no incentive to keep coaches from running a dirty program because there would be no consequence to the coach's career.

 MYTH
No coach has ever gotten another coaching job after receiving a show-cause penalty.

REALITY
Of the 44 men's basketball coaches slapped with show-causes since 2000, over half of them have later found jobs coaching again.  Below are a few examples of men who've survived an NCAA show-cause:
  • Todd Bozeman received an 8 year show-cause while at Cal. He now is the head coach at Morgan State.
  • Steve Forbes received a 1 year show-cause while he was an assistant at Tennessee.  He then became a head coach at Northwest Florida State College before accepting an assistant coaching position at Wichita State. 
  • Jason Shay received a 1 year show-cause while serving under Pearl at Tennessee.  He then became an assistant under Forbes at NFSC before accepting a position at the University of North Dakota.
  • Rob Senderoff got a 3 year show-cause while working at Indiana as an assistant coach. He is currently Kent State's head coach.
  • Brent Bargen received a 4 year show-cause while at Long Beach State & is now the head coach at Chadron State.  
  • Tommy Wade received a 2 year show-cause while he was a South Alabama assistant coach.  He is now the Director of Player Development at Oklahoma State.
MYTH
The University of Alabama would never consider a coach who has received a show-cause.

REALITY
Anyone speaking in absolutes at this point is, to be blunt, an idiot.  This will be a business decision & Battle will be making a bold statement when he chooses whether to retain Grant or look elsewhere.  Hiring Kiffin should tell you the level of faith both Battle & Saban have in our compliance department.  And those who's retort to that is Kiffin never received a show-cause, still don't understand it's intent.  Never has a coach pissed off more superiors than Kiffin.  At the very least, he has proven to be a rogue coach who openly disrespected his league commissioner, his peers, his university, & The NCAA.  So did Kiffin receive a show-cause? No.  Is he seen in a better light than Pearl to those who matter? Hell no.  But Saban saw how he could be used to improve our football program & he hired him.  Saban also believes a great basketball atmosphere is also a tremendous benefit in football recruiting, one he no longer has.  When is the last time you've heard about Saban taking a high profile recruit to a hoops game?  If your answer is any time this season, you'd be wrong.

            _______________________________________________________

Whether you are a small-time booster who writes a blog or a big-time BOT relative who posts on a message board, the simple fact is nobody knows definitively whether Grant will be fired or if Pearl would even be considered.  However, I am confident that the people who will be making those decisions will be far more educated on the term, show-cause, than many people in this fanbase.  And as a card carrying member of Team Pearl, I thank God for that....




Thanks for stopping by, y'all!!!  Roll Tide!!!  Roll Pearl!!!  Roll Webster's!!!


Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The Recruitment of Elisha Shaw

Image
A nother signing day has come & gone.  And in what has become the norm, Alabama has the #1 recruiting class, signing phenoms like Bo Scarbrough & Rashaan Evans.  Rival fanbases have already begun the annual discussions of which players on Saban's roster will be "processed" to make room for all the incoming 5 stars.  Ya know... Because the leader of the evil empire doesn't care about players.  He only cares about winning. While ESPN is ooing & awing over what might possibly be the best signing class ever, the best story of National Signing Day has gone virtually unmentioned.  The story of Elisha Shaw.  Outside of my fellow recruiting junkies, I doubt anyone's even heard his name.  At one time, Shaw was one of the top defensive tackle prospects in the nation.  With 17 scholarship offers on the table, programs like Georgia, auburn, & Florida State were all fighting for him.  But Shaw's situation changed drastically when he suffered a severe ne
Read more

Iron Bowl Problems

Image
F or the last month, I've been struggling with a really difficult life decision.  I'm not talking about where to plan my next vacation or what color to paint my kitchen, y'all.  This is MUCH MORE IMPORTANT than that....  See, I am the proud owner of a couple of Iron Bowl tickets & I've been really torn about what I should do with them.  Before you roll your eyes and label this a first world problem, hear me out & you'll understand why it's been so hard deciding should I stay or should I go. Reason #1 I really hate Auburn, y'all.  This is not your typical run of the mill kinda hate either.  I despise everything about them.  I hate their fans.  They're truly the most annoying fanbase in all of college football.  I hate the way they not only think God is a football fan but he is, in fact, an auburn fan.  I hate the way they make signs saying things like, "God Thing" while guzzling bourbon and cursing at opposing fanbases.  I hate that t
Read more

Rammer Jammer~A Video Diary

Image
H ave you ever been around that snotty nosed kid that won't accept not getting their way?  You know the one I'm talking about.  The little brat that puts his fingers in his ears while screaming, "I CAN'T HEAR YOU! I CAN'T HEAR YOU!".  Imagine about 200 of those little assholes in head to toe orange and blue.  But instead of the 'I can't hear you' mantra, they manage to come up with something even more annoying.  The auburn fight song. Yep.  This happened Saturday night, y'all.  I have clocked 5 years experience sitting next to the visiting band.  It isn't always easy but I really do love my section.  Plus, sometimes you get to score awesome pictures like this: Ironically, with 00:01 left on the clock, about 100,000 of my closest friends and I celebrated a much deserved win over our in-state rival.  Kids, I'm telling ya....  After suffering thru 2010 & 2013, the look of relief on my face would be virtually impossible to dupli
Read more